New course: The Secret Language of Hiring is now open. Enroll now →

“Can We Have Your References?” Here’s What It Means Before the Final Round.

The Secret Language of Hiring: “Can We Have Your References?” Here’s What It Means Before the Final Round.

The Secret Language of Hiring, Part 42

It sounds like an offer is on the way, and it will often mean you are a finalist, though the same request can go to the runner-up in the same week.

You finish the second interview, and before anyone schedules the final conversation, the recruiter sends a short email: “Can you send over three professional references?” Most candidates read that request as proof the offer is coming, and some will even ease off the rest of their search.

After decades of both requesting references from candidates and preparing candidates for the calls that follow, I can tell you that an early reference request will often mean one of three things. Only one of them is the version most candidates assume they are in.

Version One: You Are a Serious Finalist

This is the version you are hoping for. The hiring manager has seen enough to want you, and the team is lining up the remaining steps so an offer can follow soon after the final round. Many employers save reference checks for the people they are seriously considering. Carnegie Mellon University, for example, encourages its hiring managers to check references on semi-finalist and finalist candidates before extending an offer. If the recruiter also asks about your start date or your salary expectations in the same conversation, you are most likely in this version.

Version Two: You Are the Backup

Companies will often check references on more than one finalist at once. If the first choice declines or a reference raises a concern, the second choice is ready, and nobody loses weeks restarting the search. Hiring guidance from The University of Texas at Austin tells managers to contact at least two previous employers for each finalist, so a reference request can reach several candidates in the same week. You may be the frontrunner or the runner-up, and the request by itself won’t show you which.

As I described in “You Think a Reference Call Is a Formality?,” the reference conversation can shape a hiring decision in either direction, which is one more reason a company would rather hear from references for two finalists than one.

Version Three: A Routine Step in Their Process

Some companies collect references at a set point for every candidate who reaches a certain stage, whether or not anyone has made a decision. In that case, the request shows you where you are in their timeline rather than where you rank. As I described in “They Reposted the Job I Interviewed For,” a routine step can look more meaningful from the outside than it does to the people running the search.

What to Do When They Ask for Your References

Contact your references today. Tell each one about the role, the company, and the two or three strengths you would like them to speak to, then ask when they are available over the next week. The Military Officers Association of America recommends giving your references the job description along with the resume and cover letter you submitted, and keeping them informed throughout your search so a call never catches them off guard.

Then ask your recruiter one direct question: “Where does the reference check fall in your process, and what happens after the final round?” If they can describe the timeline in specifics, that is a good sign. If the answer is vague, you need to keep interviewing elsewhere until an offer is in writing. As I described in “We’re Being Very Selective,” timeline language will often sound more certain than the process behind it.

Finally, prepare for the possibility that the process shifts after your references are contacted. As I described in “The Hiring Manager Changed in the Middle of My Process,” a search can change direction late, even for a candidate the team liked. Keeping your other conversations active protects you if that happens.

A reference request is a good sign, and the best way to respond is to brief your references with the same care you bring to the final round.

Let’s Talk About This

Has a company ever asked for your references before the final round, and which version turned out to be true for you?

Drop a comment below. These experiences are impactful, and the more job seekers understand what is actually happening behind these moments, the better equipped they are to navigate them.

My free Secret Language of Hiring workbook decodes the phrases you hear throughout the hiring process, including what an early reference request can mean and how to prepare the people who speak for you.

I share what recruiters know that job seekers deserve to hear. Follow me so you don’t miss it.

Natalie Lemons

by Natalie Lemons

Natalie Lemons is the Founder and President of Resilience Group, LLC, and The Resilient Recruiter and Co-Founder of Need a New Gig. She specializes in the area of Executive Search and services a diverse group of national and international companies, focusing on mid to upper-level management searches in a variety of industries. For more articles like this, follow her blog

Resilient Recruiter is an Amazon Associate.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.