New course: The Secret Language of Hiring is now open. Enroll now →

“Where Else Are You Interviewing?” Here’s What They Really Want to Know.

The Secret Language of Hiring: “Where Else Are You Interviewing?” Here’s What They Really Want to Know.

The Secret Language of Hiring, Part 41

It sounds like small talk, but the answer you give will often shape how quickly the company decides to move.

The interview is going well. You’ve walked through your experience, asked a few thoughtful questions, and the conversation feels relaxed. Then the hiring manager leans back and asks, “So where else are you interviewing?” Many candidates freeze at this point. Some list every company they’ve spoken with, while others insist this is the only role they’re considering, hoping it comes across as loyalty.

After decades of running searches, I can tell you this question is rarely a trap. There are three common versions of it, and once you know which one you’re hearing, you can answer with confidence instead of guessing.

Version One: They Need to Know How Fast to Move

Sometimes the question is exactly what it sounds like: a scheduling check. If you’re close to an offer somewhere else, the hiring manager needs to know before booking the next round two weeks out. A strong finalist who accepts another job in the middle of a search can send the whole process back to the beginning, so recruiters (myself included) ask some version of this on most searches.

Candidates feel the pressure of timing just as much. Research from Robert Half, reported by Staffing Industry Analysts, found that 57% of Australian office workers would lose interest in a role if they weren’t contacted within 10 days. Hiring managers know that, and many will ask where else you’re interviewing simply to avoid losing you to a slow calendar.

Version Two: They’re Testing Your Interest

Here, the question is about commitment. If your answer makes this job sound like one of twenty applications, the hiring manager may read you as someone who will accept the first offer that comes along or leave within a year. If you claim there’s nothing else in motion, they may assume they have all the time in the world. According to The Muse, interviewers use this question to size up the competition and to gauge how likely they are to hire you, and the best answers come across as honest and interested at once.

As I described in “You’re Our Top Candidate,” how a company talks to you in the middle of a process will often depend on how sure they are that you’ll say yes. Your answer to this question feeds directly into that confidence.

Version Three: They’re Deciding How Hard to Compete for You

A competing process can push a company to accelerate, while a candidate with nothing else active may be kept waiting as the team finishes other interviews. That waiting period can look a lot like the situation I covered in “We’re Still Interviewing Other Candidates.” If they know someone else wants you, the timeline will often tighten, and the offer conversation may start sooner than planned.

Companies have good reason to take competition seriously. In research from Robert Half covering 9,000 job seekers in 11 countries, 67% said they had accepted a second-choice offer because their preferred employer took too long to decide. As I described in “We’ll Move Quickly on the Right Candidate,” speed is often reserved for the candidates a company is most afraid of losing.

What to Say When They Ask Where Else You’re Interviewing

Give an honest, general answer. You can say you’re speaking with a few companies about similar roles, then explain why this one is a priority for you (the team, the scope of the work, or the problem they’re trying to solve). If your interest is tied to something specific about their company, that is a good sign to the hiring manager that you’re a serious candidate.

Skip the specific companies and the details of where you stand with each one. Sharing them rarely helps, and it can put you in an awkward position in a small industry. Never invent a competing offer to create urgency. Recruiters compare notes more than candidates realize, and a made-up offer will often fall apart with one follow-up question.

If you are close to an offer elsewhere, tell them plainly and ask about their timeline. As I described in “They Reposted the Job I Interviewed For,” a process can change quickly after an interview, so you need to keep your other conversations moving until you have something in writing.

This question gives you a chance to explain why you chose them, and a strong answer will often keep your timeline moving without costing you any trust.

Let’s Talk About This

How do you answer when an interviewer asks where else you’re interviewing?

Drop a comment below. These experiences are impactful, and the more job seekers understand what is actually happening behind these moments, the better equipped they are to navigate them.

My free Secret Language of Hiring workbook decodes the phrases you hear throughout the hiring process, including the questions interviewers ask to gauge your interest and your timeline.

I share what recruiters know that job seekers deserve to hear. Follow me so you don’t miss it.

Natalie Lemons

by Natalie Lemons

Natalie Lemons is the Founder and President of Resilience Group, LLC, and The Resilient Recruiter and Co-Founder of Need a New Gig. She specializes in the area of Executive Search and services a diverse group of national and international companies, focusing on mid to upper-level management searches in a variety of industries. For more articles like this, follow her blog

Resilient Recruiter is an Amazon Associate.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.