New course: The Secret Language of Hiring is now open. Enroll now →

Turning Down a Job Offer Without Burning the Bridge? Here’s What to Say.

Turning Down a Job Offer Without Burning the Bridge? Here’s What to Say.

The recruiter you turn down this week may be the one who calls you about a better role in a few years, and how you deliver your no will often decide whether that call ever comes.

You have an offer you have decided not to take, and now you need to tell a company that spent weeks interviewing you that the answer is no. Many candidates dread this conversation so much that they put it off, soften it until the message gets lost, or try to get the company to walk away first.

After decades of extending offers on behalf of clients and taking the calls when candidates decline them, I can tell you that recruiters will often forget which candidates turned them down. What they remember is how each one handled it. The way you deliver this news can keep a door open for years, or close it before you hang up.

Why Speed Comes Before Your Reason

When you hold an offer, the company is usually holding its other finalists in place. The runner-up is on hold, the hiring manager is expecting news, and the recruiter is fielding questions from both sides about when there will be an answer. Each day you spend deciding how to phrase your decision is a day the second choice might accept somewhere else.

For that reason, most recruiters care more about how fast they hear from you than about why you are declining. Career guidance from USC Online advises candidates to decline within a few days instead of letting the decision drag on for a week or more. If you already know your answer, waiting until the deadline gains you nothing and costs the company options it was counting on.

As I described in “We’re Just Finalizing Offer Details,” the stretch between a verbal offer and a signed one is often busier behind the scenes than candidates realize, and a late decline can unravel plans that were already in motion.

The Two Ways Candidates Burn the Bridge

The first mistake is stalling until the last possible moment, hoping the right words will come. The company keeps the role open the whole time, and when the decline finally arrives, the recruiter has to restart conversations with candidates who may have moved on.

The second mistake is harder to spot from the candidate’s side. Some people try to avoid saying no by coming back with an unreasonable list of demands, like a much higher salary, extra remote days and a bigger title, hoping the company will withdraw the offer for them. The recruiter can then spend days going back and forth with the hiring manager over an offer you were never going to take. When the company figures out what happened (and it will often figure it out), you are remembered as the candidate who wasn’t straight with them.

Over-explaining creates its own problems. A list of everything you disliked about the company, or the exact figures in your other offer, can turn a polite decline into a negotiation. As I described in “The Counteroffer: Still a Trap,” once money becomes the whole conversation, the original reasons behind a decision tend to get lost, so if you have decided, you don’t need to reopen that discussion.

What to Say and How to Say It

Call as soon as you have decided, and keep the call to about thirty seconds. Writing for SHRM, Johnny C. Taylor, Jr. recommends turning down an offer verbally to the recruiter or hiring manager first, and then putting it in writing. A phone call shows respect for the time the team invested in you, and it gives the recruiter a chance to ask a question if they have one.

You can say something like this: “Thank you for the offer, and for the time your team put into the process. I’ve decided to take a different role, and I wanted you to hear it from me right away. I enjoyed getting to know the team, and I hope we can stay in touch.” If you haven’t accepted another position, you can say, “I’ve decided this isn’t the right fit for me right now.”

If the recruiter asks what it would take to change your mind, and you know the answer is nothing, you can say, “It really came down to fit, but I appreciate you asking.” If you have already decided, you need to decline directly instead of asking for terms you know they can’t meet.

Then send a short email that repeats the same message, so there is a record of your decision. Leave out pay and title comparisons. If you know someone who would suit the role, offer to pass their contact information along. Recruiters will often remember that gesture longer than the decline itself.

As I described in “You Gave Your Notice – Then the Offer Disappeared,” plans can change quickly after you commit to a new opportunity, and the recruiter you treat well today may be the person you need to call later.

A clear no, said quickly and politely, will often leave a better impression than a yes that took three weeks.

Let’s Talk About This

Have you ever turned down a job offer, and how did you tell them?

Drop a comment below. These experiences are impactful, and the more job seekers understand what is actually happening behind these moments, the better equipped they are to navigate them.

My free Secret Language of Hiring workbook decodes the phrases you hear throughout the hiring process, including what recruiters mean when they ask what it would take to change your mind.

I share what recruiters know that job seekers deserve to hear. Follow me so you don’t miss it.

Natalie Lemons

by Natalie Lemons

Natalie Lemons is the Founder and President of Resilience Group, LLC, and The Resilient Recruiter and Co-Founder of Need a New Gig. She specializes in the area of Executive Search and services a diverse group of national and international companies, focusing on mid to upper-level management searches in a variety of industries. For more articles like this, follow her blog

Resilient Recruiter is an Amazon Associate.

Ready to put this into practice? Search open roles across the US on the job board. Search open jobs

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.